Pindula
Register Login

Ban On Bank Lending Has No Legal Force - Experts

Ban On Bank Lending Has No Legal Force - Experts

Legal experts say President Emmerson Mnangagwa’s ban on bank lending has no legal force.

On Saturday, Mnangagwa banned banks from lending to both corporates and individuals as one of the measures meant to stabilise the local currency, the Zimbabwe dollar/RTGS dollar.

On Monday, the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe (RBZ) ordered banks to take heed of Mnangagwa’s announcement and threatened to take action against non-compliant banks.

United Kingdom-based lawyer Alex Magaisa said Mnangagwa’s decree has no legal foundation and there is no law compelling banks to comply with such measures. Wrote Magaisa:

This is a shameful document by Zimbabwe’s central bank. Since it knows the decree has no legal foundation it distances itself by calling it a ‘Presidential Announcement’.

There is no legal instrument under Zimbabwe’s laws called a ‘Presidential Announcement’.

He could have used the Presidential Powers (Temporary Measures) Act even if that would still be controversial. But no, he couldn’t be bothered.

And here the central bank colludes in the lawbreaking by purporting to enforce the illegal decree. But the pliant banks will oblige.

Lawyer Obey Shava concurred with Magaisa, saying there is no law giving effect to the President’s announcement. Added Shava:

Banks are not legally obliged to act upon this RBZ directive.

CCC spokesperson and lawyer, Fadzayi Mahere warned that if banks fail to challenge the directive, it will be the end of banking law as we know it. Mahere said:

This decree is unconstitutional in its substance and ultra vires the law.

You can’t undo the entire law of banking, violate the constitutional right to trade and freedom of commerce — and do so by memo!

If banks don’t challenge this, it will be the end of banking law as we know it.

However, in an interview with NewsDay, corporate lawyer Rodgers Matsikidze said the RBZ directive remains binding on banks unless they challenge it in the courts. Said Matsikidze:

Basically, what the President did was pronounce policies.

The relevant procedure was that the relevant minister should have drafted the legal principles of the policies and submitted them to the Attorney-General.

The President could have used the Presidential Powers Act to enact a law on economic policies.

In the meantime, RBZ has proceeded to issue a statement on the announced measures and unless that is set aside by a court of law, it remains binding.

RBZ is a regulator, so unless its directive is challenged in a court of law.

More: NewsDay

Share Article

Sponsored

More

3 Comments

Tkt 1 month ago

Well, it's quite a bad move by the Gvt to restrict free trade but in thus case I'm glad my learned friend wamagaisa knows of the existence of the law inonzi Presidential Powers
That's exactly what the leader of the house used
Now back to it's effects, it must be understood that banks can survive VERY WELL without lending anyone anything on taxes and levies
Saka hapana choshamisa apo nezvaitwa nemukuru bcoz the same banks who are supposed to help tge Central Bank in controlling inflation are well engaged in activities fueling inflationary pressures.

Look at the interests rates from the 40% Overnight Accommodation by the Central Bank, mm that rate must be well bellow 10% as already banks are troubling to settle the same, hence pass done the effects to ordinary bankers

I say, RBZ
1- reduce and remove some levies to promote use of the local currency
2- delay processing period for ZIPIT services by between 2-6hrs depending on the amounts transfered this will reduce rate at which money is moved from individual to individual for currency manipulation
3- hazvi nyadzise kuprinter a higher denomination NOTE even upto 1000 then introduce comprehensive messures on dealing with run-away inflation

Ndatenda


999l 1 month ago

aaaah yaah nyika iyi kana
freedom to trade and commerce yatoenda..
banks need to challenge this in court coz next time uchamzwa vakuti zupco banks chete to operate


VYBZ KARTEL 1 month ago

GINYAECONOMICS KKKKK NDOZVATINOITA. TINOIPONDA NYIKA. HATINA BASA NEVANHU ISU.



Leave a comment


Recent News


News Categories



Give us Feedback